Our Point of View

TIME100 Philanthropy: Who the Spotlight Leaves Out

Before we begin . . .

We’re kicking off our Substack the only way we know how: by challenging the dominant narrative.

This isn’t a welcome post or a mission statement — you can read who we are here.

What we’re sharing below is what this space is for: clear, unapologetic commentary on the systems shaping our world and the stories that keep them intact.

Philanthropy’s Power Problem

TIME magazine’s TIME100 Philanthropy list, celebrating the “100 most influential people shaping the future of giving at a pivotal moment,” reads like a society column. Perhaps that was the intent. But if so, let’s be honest about what’s being spotlighted: philanthropic celebrity.

To frame this group as the visionaries shaping the future of giving — without context, critique, or inclusion of grassroots perspectives — is to conflate visibility with vision, and power with progress.

The issue isn’t with who’s included — many of the individuals and institutions named are making real contributions. The problem is the premise: that billionaires, celebrities, and major foundation leaders are the ones shaping the future of giving. That idea doesn’t deserve celebration. It deserves scrutiny.

This framing reinforces a troubling power imbalance: one in which those who benefit most from inequality are also entrusted with solving it — where determining public priorities is a privilege reserved for those with private wealth or cultural capital. Where impact in philanthropy stems not from lived experience or proximity to harm, but from the ability to write a check or draw an audience.

Too often, philanthropy — especially in the hands of concentrated wealth — has become a form of privatized policy-making. It’s unelected power deciding which communities matter, which issues get traction, and which solutions are deemed worthy of investment. It is profoundly undemocratic — and instead of questioning that, the TIME100 list affirms and amplifies it.

We don’t need another echo chamber that elevates the already-elevated. We need a deeper, more honest conversation about who philanthropy is accountable to — and who is consistently left out of the frame. Because the truth is, change isn’t being engineered in boardrooms or ballrooms. It’s being built on the ground by organizers, mutual aid networks, community leaders, and everyday people doing the work with scarce resources and even less recognition.

Had TIME simply called this a list of top donors or philanthropic power players, that would have been more accurate. But to frame this group as the visionaries shaping the future of giving — without context, critique, or inclusion of grassroots perspectives — is to conflate visibility with vision, and power with progress.

At this pivotal moment, we don’t need philanthropy that mirrors social hierarchies or seeks legacy-building. We need a new model — one that listens more than it leads, follows the wisdom of those closest to the problems, and redistributes not just wealth but decision-making. The future of giving should be defined not by who has the most, but by who we choose to center.



Get new posts by email

Join the conversation on Substack (opens in a new tab)