Our Point of View

The GoFundMe Page We Never Created

When platforms profit from generosity, trust is what gets lost.

A few weeks ago, buried in an email, was this line: “Is GoFundMe Pro competing with nonprofits?”

We followed the links, dug deeper, and discovered that GoFundMe had created a fundraising page for mBOLDen Change — without our knowledge or consent.

Our name. Our mission. Our logo. A “Donate” button.

It looked legitimate. But, it wasn’t ours.

Then we learned they’d done this to 1.4 million nonprofits across the country.

Over a million organizations — from small community groups to national charities — now have GoFundMe pages they didn’t ask for, controlled by a company that profits from those donations.


What’s Actually Happening

Here’s how it works: GoFundMe uses its search dominance to direct donors to these unauthorized pages instead of to a nonprofit’s own website. When someone donates through GoFundMe, the company takes its processing fees, encourages donors to leave “tips” for GoFundMe itself, and holds the money for up to 45 days before releasing it.

So a donation sits for weeks, then arrives with above-market fees deducted. But here’s the deeper problem: while the funds eventually reach us, we often have no way to thank the donor, share what their gift accomplished, or build a relationship.

The donation (or rather a part of it) arrives. The donor doesn’t.

That missing connection isn’t just inconvenient — it’s the difference between a transaction and a partnership. It’s how we report back on impact, invite supporters to events, share stories from the field, and ask for continued support when it matters most. Direct relationships are how nonprofits survive and grow.

By creating these pages without consent, GoFundMe inserts itself between nonprofits and their supporters: using our names and missions to drive its own revenue while severing the bonds that make organizations like ours sustainable.

This isn’t partnership.

It’s extraction.


The Bigger Picture

GoFundMe isn’t alone in using business practices that disadvantage nonprofits. Other common platforms — including Benevity and Facebook Fundraisers — present themselves as bridges between donors and nonprofits while profiting from being in the middle. They take a cut, hold funds for weeks or months, and keep the donor data that organizations need to build and sustain relationships.

Some argue these platforms expand reach and make giving easier. They’re right that some nonprofits genuinely benefit from using them. That’s a valid choice and there’s nothing wrong with it.

But choice is the key word.

As we often say: “Nothing about us, without us.”

The issue isn’t whether platforms can be useful. It’s that GoFundMe created 1.4 million pages without asking permission. They made a choice on behalf of nonprofits that should have been ours to make.

When platforms prioritize their own growth over nonprofit consent and autonomy, they’re not solving a problem — they’re creating one.

To most donors, it feels seamless: click, confirm, done.

To nonprofits, it’s another layer of cost, delay, and disconnection.

This model doesn’t build trust.

It borrows it. Then profits from it.


What You Can Do

If you are a nonprofit: Check whether GoFundMe has created a page for your organization. They probably did. Decide whether you’re comfortable with that, and consider whether to claim it, remove it, or publicly clarify with your donors.

We weren’t comfortable, so we acted quickly to have the unauthorized page taken down.

If you are a donor: Give directly through a nonprofit’s own website and its chosen giving platform. That’s the best way to ensure your gift, your information, and your trust reach the people doing the work.

Trust and connection are our most precious resources. When you give directly, nonprofits can thank you personally, show you the impact of your gift, and invite you deeper into the mission you’re supporting.


Get new posts by email

Join the conversation on Substack (opens in a new tab)