Our Point of View

Public Education Should Be a Federally Protected Civil Right

Public education has long been a pillar of American society — but it has never been guaranteed as a federally protected right.

In the 1973 case San Antonio Independent School District v. Rodriguez, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the Constitution does not explicitly guarantee a right to education. While the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection and Due Process Clauses provide some important safeguards, they have never been enough to ensure that every student receives a high-quality, equitable education.

That’s why the federal government has a critical role to play.


Why We Need a Federal Role in Education

In 1979, President Jimmy Carter established the U.S. Department of Education (DOE) to bring together fragmented federal education programs under one roof. His goal was ambitious: to ensure the federal government actively enforced civil rights laws, tackled systemic inequities, and guaranteed that all students — regardless of race, income, geography, or ability — had equal access to a quality education.

Since its founding, the Department of Education has played a vital role in protecting students’ civil rights, providing funding to underserved districts, supporting students with disabilities, and ensuring that states meet basic standards of equity and inclusion.

Now, that critical role is under attack.

The current administration is pushing to eliminate the Department of Education altogether, arguing that education should be returned fully to the states. They say it’s about reducing bureaucracy and restoring “local values.” But the truth is, it’s about weakening students’ civil rights and accountability while paving the way for privatization, school vouchers, and a patchwork system where access to a quality, equitable education depends entirely on a child’s zip code.


What’s at Stake Now

We’ve seen this before — and we still see it today. While the creation of the Department of Education helped reduce some of the most glaring disparities in access and funding, inequities persist. Black, brown, immigrant, rural, low-income students, and students with disabilities continue to face systemic barriers.

Without federal standards and oversight, who will fight for them? Who will hold states accountable? Dismantling the Department of Education would reverse hard-won progress and deepen inequities for students across the country.

The Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights (OCR) shows us why federal enforcement matters. Since its founding, OCR has protected students by collecting data on opportunity gaps, issuing civil rights guidance, and investigating discrimination.

  • In Cleveland, OCR found that Latinx students — 14% of the Cleveland Metropolitan School District’s population — were denied equitable access to STEM programs due to school placements and the lack of Spanish-language outreach.

  • In Henrico County, Virginia, OCR uncovered stark disparities in advanced coursework, graduation rates, and test performance between predominantly Black and white schools.

These are just two of thousands of investigations that have led to concrete changes — ensuring more equitable access to learning opportunities for millions of students.

As AFL-CIO President Liz Shuler warns:

“Shuttering the Department of Education is a radical plan, ripped from the pages of Project 2025, that will close the doors of opportunity for America’s students. Without the Department of Education, working people will have one more hurdle to access the financial aid they need to go to college or pursue a trade. Kids from working-class families — especially kids with disabilities — will be left behind, unable to access the education they need to succeed. States, cities, and towns will be forced to stretch their already tight budgets to cover the loss in federal funding, jeopardizing essential programs.”


What We Stand to Lose

Public education must be more than a patchwork of local policy decisions. It must be a civil right—one that is protected, resourced, and enforced at the federal level.

Eliminating the Department of Education would:

  • Deepen inequality across states and districts

  • Strip away critical civil rights protections

  • Undermine the federal commitment to students with disabilities, English learners, and low-income communities

  • Leave rural and underserved areas without the federal support they rely on

A country that enables educational inequity squanders the potential of millions of future workers, thinkers, dreamers, and leaders.

Public education is not a privilege. It’s a necessity.

It should reflect our highest values — not the lowest bar each state is willing to set.

It’s time we treat it like a federally protected civil right.


Take Action

📣 Submit a Public Comment by June 20

The U.S. Department of Education is collecting public comments on a major policy shift:

“Priorities, Requirements, Definitions, and Selection Criteria: Evidence-Based Literacy, Education Choice, and Returning Education to the States”

(Docket ID: ED–2025–OS–0020)

This proposed rule paves the way for dismantling the Department of Education, shifting responsibility to the states, and expanding privatization efforts through vouchers and charter programs. It directly threatens federal protections for students with disabilities, English learners, and those in low-income and rural communities.

Submit your public comment by June 20 to make your voice heard.

👉 Go to www.regulations.gov

👉 Search: ED-2025-OS-0020

👉 Click the title: Priorities, Requirements, Definitions, and Selection Criteria…

👉 Hit “Comment”

Tell the Department:

  • You OPPOSE dismantling the Department of Education

  • You SUPPORT protecting students’ civil rights and equitable access to opportunity

  • Returning education to the states — without federal accountability — is not reform. It’s regression.


🗳️ Contact Your Elected Officials

The President cannot eliminate the Department of Education without Congressional approval. That means your voice — and your vote — can help stop this.

Tell them: Protect public education and the civil rights of our students. Oppose efforts to dismantle the Department of Education.

Use this tool from Common Cause to call or email your representatives.

📧 Sample Message to Send

Subject: Defend Public Education and Civil Rights — Protect the Department of Education

Dear [Representative/Senator],

I am deeply concerned about efforts to dismantle the U.S. Department of Education. This proposal is not about streamlining government — it’s about walking away from our national commitment to educational equity.

The Department of Education plays a critical role in enforcing civil rights, supporting students with disabilities and English learners, and ensuring that schools serving low-income and rural communities receive the resources they need. Eliminating it would roll back decades of hard-won progress and harm millions of students.

Public education should reflect our highest values — not the lowest bar each state is willing to set. I urge you to stand firmly against any attempt to weaken or abolish the Department of Education. Our students — and our democracy — depend on it.

Sincerely,

[Your Name]

[Your Zip Code]


Get new posts by email

Join the conversation on Substack (opens in a new tab)